Finding the right surrogacy agency means evaluating how they screen surrogates, support both you and your surrogate, handle legal agreements, and guide you through a complex medical and emotional process. A responsible agency verifies surrogate health and psychological fitness, clarifies all costs upfront, manages communication between parties, and works with attorneys to protect everyone involved.
Surrogacy is an expensive, lengthy path to parenthood—typically 18 to 24 months from agency selection to birth. The agency you choose shapes how supported you feel, how protected your legal rights are, and how the relationship with your surrogate unfolds. This guide walks you through what to look for, what questions to ask, and which agencies practices should raise concern.
Table of Contents
- What a Surrogacy Agency Actually Does
- Verifying Credentials and Legal Standing
- Understanding the Surrogate Screening Process
- What to Ask About the Matching Process
- Transparent Pricing and Hidden Costs
- Legal Protections and Contracts
- Support Services Throughout the Journey
- Common Red Flags and Agencies to Avoid
- Questions to Ask Before Committing
- Next Steps After Choosing an Agency
- Frequently Asked Questions
What a Surrogacy Agency Actually Does
A surrogacy agency is an intermediary that recruits and screens surrogates, matches them with intended parents, coordinates medical care, manages legal paperwork, and provides support throughout the journey. They do not perform medical procedures—fertility clinics and hospitals do—but they prepare everyone involved for the path ahead.
Agencies vary in size and scope. Large national agencies maintain offices in multiple states and work with dozens of fertility clinics. Smaller boutique agencies may focus on a single region or a particular approach (such as gestational surrogacy only, or support for intended parents with specific religious or cultural values). Some are nonprofit; others are for-profit companies.
Gestational surrogacy, where the surrogate carries an embryo created from your egg and sperm (or donor egg and sperm), is the most common form in the United States. Traditional surrogacy, where the surrogate is also the biological mother, is rare and raises different legal questions. Most agencies handle gestational surrogacy only; ask which form they offer.
Agencies also differ in how much hand-holding they provide. Some manage almost everything—coordinating with fertility clinics, keeping both sides informed, arranging counseling, and attending medical appointments. Others function more as matchmakers and leave many logistics to the intended parents and attorneys. Neither model is inherently better, but knowing what you'll handle yourself matters for your budget and stress level.
The agency should explain their process in writing before you hire them: how they screen surrogates, what your costs are, what you pay if the match doesn't work out, and what support is included. Ask for this information in your first conversation so you can compare multiple agencies fairly.
Verifying Credentials and Legal Standing
No federal license governs surrogacy agencies. The fertility industry is regulated at state and federal levels, but individual agencies are not licensed the way hospitals are. This means your due diligence is your only real guarantee of professionalism. start by checking whether the agency is accredited.
The American Academy of Assisted Reproductive Technology Professionals (AAARP) and the Society for Assisted Reproductive Technology (SART) maintain directories and set practice standards. Accreditation does not mean an agency is perfect, but it signals that they have committed to meeting established criteria and can be evaluated against them. Look up the agency in your state's consumer protection database.
Check the Better Business Bureau for complaints and resolutions. Search the agency name online along with words like "complaint," "lawsuit," or "fraud"—not because one negative review means something, but because patterns of serious problems should be visible. Ask the agency for references from previous clients willing to talk with you. A good agency can provide five to ten names of people who have completed their process.
Call at least three. Ask what surprised them, whether they felt supported, whether the agency was transparent about costs, and whether they would recommend it. Ask who owns the agency and who will be your primary contact. An owner with formal training in assisted reproduction, law, or social work brings relevant expertise. Your contact person should have specific credentials or several years of experience, not just a title.
This person will be crucial when problems arise—and they usually do. Verify that the agency works with licensed attorneys experienced in surrogacy law in your state. Your attorney and the surrogate's attorney should be separate people to avoid conflicts of interest. The agency should name these attorneys and explain what legal services are included in their fee.
Understanding the Surrogate Screening Process
The agency's surrogate screening is where your actual safety begins. ask the agency in detail: How do they recruit surrogates? What medical and psychological requirements do they enforce? How thoroughly do they verify a surrogate's background? Medical requirements typically include: age 21 to 45, at least one prior uncomplicated pregnancy and delivery, BMI under 32 (or similar), no serious chronic illness, no current substance use, and normal results on bloodwork, pelvic ultrasound, and psychological evaluation.
A good agency will explain why each requirement exists—older surrogates or those with significant prior complications have higher medical risk, for example. Ask how the agency verifies previous pregnancies and deliveries. Do they contact OBs directly? Do they request delivery records? A surrogate who claims she had uncomplicated deliveries should have documentation to support that.
Red flags include vague answers, a refusal to obtain records, or a surrogate with multiple prior miscarriages or pregnancy complications not fully explained. Psychological screening should include an in-depth evaluation by a licensed mental health professional (a psychologist or social worker), not just a brief questionnaire. The evaluator should assess the surrogate's motivation for being a surrogate, her understanding of what the process entails, her ability to hand over the baby, her support system, and any history of depression, anxiety, trauma, or substance use.
A single screening is standard; repeat evaluations are rare but reasonable if years pass between cycles. Background checks should include criminal history, child abuse and neglect records, and sometimes credit history. Ask what the agency considers disqualifying. Many agencies exclude anyone with felony convictions or a history of child abuse; others have more flexible policies.
Know what the agency's standards are and whether they match yours. Drug screening is standard. Ask whether the agency screens for recreational drugs, prescription opioids, and whether they monitor throughout the pregnancy. A surrogate who uses substances during pregnancy directly endangers the baby's health, so this screening matters.
What to Ask About the Matching Process
Once you and a surrogate are both screened and available, the agency begins the matching process. This is highly personal and high-stakes for everyone—it shapes the entire journey. Ask the agency: How do they match intended parents with surrogates? Can you reject a match? Can the surrogate reject you? What happens if a match doesn't work out? A good agency will present multiple profiles, not rush a match, and allow both sides time to decide.
You should see the surrogate's medical summary, background, motivation for surrogacy, and often a photo and personal statement. She should see similar information about you: your reason for pursuing surrogacy, your plan for medical care, and your expectations about communication and contact. Many intended parents worry about genetic connection when using their own egg and sperm, but little else, while others prioritize religion, education level, health history, or lifestyle.
The surrogate may prioritize whether you want ongoing contact after birth, how often you'll communicate during pregnancy, and what kind of relationship she hopes to have with the child. These conversations are critical and should happen before you agree to work together. Ask what happens if the match fails—if you and the surrogate cannot work together, or if one party wants out.
Does the agency charge you again to rematch? Can you get a refund or credit? How long does rematch typically take? Some agencies include one rematch in their fee; others charge for it. Know this before it happens. Some agencies include a "trial period" where you and the surrogate meet virtually or by phone before formally agreeing.
This is worthwhile because mismatched expectations about communication or style can derail the cycle later. If the agency doesn't offer this, ask whether you can arrange it yourself.
Transparent Pricing and Hidden Costs
Surrogacy is expensive—typically $120,000 to $200,000 from agency fees through birth, though exact costs vary widely by agency, location, fertility clinic, and whether this is your first cycle or a rematch. Many intended parents are surprised by costs that weren't clearly explained upfront. Ask the agency for an itemized list of all fees in writing.
Standard agency fees typically cover surrogate recruitment, screening, matching, coordination with medical and legal professionals, and support services. This might range from $15,000 to $40,000. Separate from the agency fee, you will pay the surrogate's medical expenses (pregnancy-related costs not covered by her insurance), the surrogate's base compensation (typically $20,000 to $50,000), and legal fees for both the intended parent and surrogate ($5,000 to $15,000 each).
Fertility clinic costs (stimulation, retrieval, and embryo transfer) are additional. Ask which costs are included in the agency fee and which are billed separately. Some agencies bundle more services; others separate them. Neither is inherently wrong, but clarity matters so you can compare agencies accurately. Ask about insurance: Does the surrogate's health insurance cover pregnancy? If not, does the agency or do you pay for pregnancy insurance? Pregnancy insurance can cost several thousand dollars and is easy to overlook.
Ask what you pay if the match fails and you need to rematch, if the surrogate has a miscarriage, if the cycle doesn't result in a viable embryo, or if you cancel before the surrogate is pregnant. Some agencies refund or credit certain fees in these scenarios; others do not. This is painful to discuss but essential to know upfront.
Ask whether the surrogate's lost wages during recovery, childcare costs during medical appointments, and travel expenses are included in the compensation or billed to you separately. Small costs add up quickly. Some agencies include these in their quoted fee; others surprise you with invoices months later. Request a sample contract or fee schedule from the agency showing what you would owe at each stage of the process.
This lets you understand the full timeline and cost structure before committing. Do not commit to an agency that refuses to explain costs in writing.
Legal Protections and Contracts
Surrogacy law varies significantly by state. Some states explicitly allow compensated surrogacy and have clear legal processes; others prohibit it or leave the law ambiguous. Your state's laws and the surrogate's state's laws will both matter. A good agency will explain the legal landscape in your jurisdiction and work only with experienced surrogacy attorneys. Your contract with the surrogate should be reviewed by an attorney in your state and should cover: the surrogate's medical and legal rights and obligations, your financial responsibilities, what happens if complications occur, who makes medical decisions if the surrogate is incapacitated, whether you can terminate the pregnancy, what contact (if any) the surrogate will have with the child after birth, and how disputes will be resolved.
Before beginning the cycle, you and the surrogate should both have your own independent attorneys review and approve the contract. This costs extra but prevents conflicts of interest and ensures both sides understand what they are agreeing to. Never ask a surrogate to waive legal representation. Ask the agency whether pre-birth orders are available in your state.
A pre-birth order is a court judgment that lists you as the legal parent before the baby is born, which can simplify the process significantly. Some states grant these readily; others do not. In states without pre-birth orders, you will likely need to adopt the baby after birth to be listed on the birth certificate.
This adds time and cost but is necessary. Clarify what happens to any embryos left over after your surrogate conceives. Will the agency or fertility clinic store them? Who decides their future? Can you use them if you want more children? The contract should address this, though laws vary by state. Ask the agency about travel and residency requirements.
Some states require you or the surrogate to reside there during certain phases. California, for example, has clear surrogacy law and no residency requirement, while other states are less predictable. Know whether you will need to travel or arrange temporary housing.
Support Services Throughout the Journey
Surrogacy is not just a medical process—it is an emotional and interpersonal journey. The agency's role in supporting both you and the surrogate during this time shapes how much stress you experience. Ask what support services are included. Counseling for the surrogate is standard and usually required. The agency should arrange psychological support before, during, and after the pregnancy.
This helps ensure the surrogate processes her emotions and is prepared to hand over the baby. Some agencies include limited counseling for intended parents as well; others do not. If not included, find an infertility counselor or therapist experienced in surrogacy to help you navigate the emotional aspects. Ask whether the agency facilitates communication between you and the surrogate.
Will the agency relay messages, manage boundaries if communication becomes tense, and mediate if conflicts arise? Some agencies are very hands-on; others expect you to communicate directly. If you communicate directly, be prepared for the surrogate to feel hurt by insensitivity or to have different expectations about what should happen during pregnancy. Clear, frequent communication prevents many problems.
Ask whether the agency provides education about what to expect medically during the pregnancy and after birth. Will they explain the hormone stimulation process, the embryo transfer, changes during pregnancy, and what happens in the hospital when the baby is born? Not all agencies provide this, but it helps reduce anxiety if they do. Ask whether the agency will support you through a difficult outcome—such as a miscarriage or a baby born with an unexpected health condition.
Will they help you process the grief or guide you through medical decisions? This matters less if everything goes smoothly but becomes crucial if it doesn't. Some agencies organize in-person meetings between you and the surrogate during pregnancy or at birth. Some leave this entirely to you. Knowing your agency's role clarifies expectations. Many surrogates value ongoing contact with the intended parents and seeing the child grow; others prefer a clean break after birth. This should be discussed and documented before you match.
Common Red Flags and Agencies to Avoid
Certain agency practices should concern you and warrant moving to a different agency. Be wary if the agency cannot or will not provide references from previous clients, if multiple references describe feeling unsupported or manipulated, or if the BBB file shows unresolved complaints. Avoid agencies that pressure you to decide quickly or that do not allow time to think.
Legitimate agencies understand that you need to evaluate this carefully and will not rush you. Avoid agencies that do not use licensed attorneys experienced in surrogacy law or that try to pair one attorney with both the intended parents and the surrogate. A single attorney creates a conflict of interest and leaves someone unprotected legally.
Avoid agencies with unclear pricing that refuse to provide a written itemized fee schedule. If an agency cannot explain what you are paying for or why, that is a sign of poor business practices or worse. Avoid agencies that screen surrogates very minimally or that do not require psychological evaluation. A surrogate's medical and mental health fitness directly affects your outcome.
Minimal screening saves the agency money but puts you at risk. Avoid agencies that have had multiple complaints about surrogates being pressured to continue pregnancies against their wishes, being coerced into medical decisions, or being abandoned financially if something goes wrong. These raise ethical and legal red flags. Avoid agencies that place emphasis on surrogates who are very young, impoverished, or from outside the United States without clear, ethical oversight.
While international surrogacy exists, it raises additional ethical and legal complexity. Research the fertility clinics the agency partners with. An agency that partners with reputable, well-established clinics is more likely to have vetted partners who will support the process properly.
Questions to Ask Before Committing
Before you sign a contract or pay a deposit, ask these specific questions and get answers in writing. How many intended parent clients do you work with each year? This helps gauge the agency's size and capacity to support you. How many cycles have your surrogates had? A surrogate having her first pregnancy is riskier than one who has had one or two prior uncomplicated pregnancies.
Ask what the agency's average is. Do you screen all surrogates the same way, or do standards vary? There should be a consistent screening protocol applied to everyone. What percentage of your matches result in a pregnancy and a live birth? While no agency can guarantee outcomes, some have much higher success rates than others.
This reflects both the quality of their medical partnerships and the surrogates they recruit. What is your refund or credit policy if the match fails, the surrogate miscarries, or you need to cancel? This should be in writing and should be clear about which circumstances allow refunds and which do not. How long is the typical wait time between agreeing to work with your agency and matching with a surrogate? This ranges from weeks to months depending on demand and available surrogates.
Longer wait times are not necessarily bad, but knowing what to expect helps you plan. Will you provide support after the baby is born? Many surrogates struggle postpartum, and you may need guidance about what to expect from the surrogate or how to navigate ongoing contact. A good agency does not disappear after delivery. Can I speak directly with my point person at your agency if I have a problem or concern? Know how accessible the agency is and who your main contact will be. If the agency is hard to reach or relies on email only, that is problematic.
Next Steps After Choosing an Agency
Once you have selected an agency and signed the contract, the typical timeline is: preliminary screening and matching (1-3 months), working with attorneys on the surrogacy contract (1-2 months), medical screenings and cycle preparation (1-2 months), embryo creation and transfer (varies), and pregnancy through delivery (9 months). The total time from agency selection to birth is typically 18 to 24 months.
Before your first appointment, make sure you have health insurance that covers you and your intended family. Some insurance plans exclude coverage for surrogacy-related care or for children born through surrogacy. Check your policy and consider additional coverage if needed. Arrange for legal counsel in your state early. You do not need to wait until you match with a surrogate—an attorney can review your agency contract and advise you on state-specific legal requirements while you are still evaluating.
This usually costs a consultation fee but prevents expensive problems later. Open a financial account or work with an escrow service if you will be handling large payments. Some agencies use third-party escrow to hold intended parent funds and release them at each stage, protecting both you and the surrogate from being cheated. Connect with support groups for intended parents pursuing surrogacy.
Local or online communities offer practical advice, emotional support, and a chance to ask questions of people who have been through the process. These connections are invaluable when you hit difficult moments. Keep detailed records of all communication with the agency, all payments made, all medical records, and all contact with the surrogate. If disputes arise later, documentation protects you.
Some intended parents use a shared document or shared email folder with the agency and surrogate to keep communication transparent and timestamped. Do not commit all your resources to one cycle. If the first attempt does not result in a pregnancy or results in a miscarriage, you may need funds for a second or third cycle with the same surrogate or a different one. Plan for this possibility financially and emotionally.
- —
Frequently Asked Questions
What should I look for in a surrogacy agency?
Look for accreditation through SART or AAARP, verified references from past clients, clear written pricing, licensed attorneys on staff, thorough surrogate screening including medical and psychological evaluation, and responsiveness when you have concerns. Cross-check complaints with the Better Business Bureau and search online for any history of legal disputes.
How much does a surrogacy agency cost?
Agency fees typically range from $15,000 to $40,000, but your total out-of-pocket cost from start to birth is usually $120,000 to $200,000 when you include surrogate compensation, medical expenses, legal fees, fertility clinic costs, and insurance. Ask for an itemized fee schedule from any agency you are considering so you can compare total costs accurately.
What medical screening should a surrogate have?
A surrogate should have bloodwork, ultrasound, medical history review confirming at least one prior uncomplicated pregnancy, age typically between 21 and 45, BMI under 32, and a clean background check. She should also complete a psychological evaluation with a licensed mental health professional to confirm she understands the process and is emotionally prepared to hand over the baby after birth.
What happens if the surrogate and I do not match well together?
A good agency allows both you and the surrogate time to decide whether to proceed and should clarify upfront what happens if the match fails. Some agencies include one rematch in their fee; others charge for rematching. Ask this question before you hire the agency so you know your options if the relationship does not work.
Do I need my own lawyer for a surrogacy agreement?
Yes. You should have your own attorney review and approve the surrogacy contract, and the surrogate should have a separate attorney representing her interests. This prevents conflicts of interest and ensures everyone understands their legal obligations and rights. Do not use a single attorney for both parties.
What happens to leftover embryos after my surrogate becomes pregnant?
This should be addressed in your contract with the surrogate and the fertility clinic. Typically, you and the surrogate discuss options—storage for future use, donation to research, or disposal—and the contract documents your joint decision. If you want more children later, you may be able to use frozen embryos with the same or a different surrogate.
